Choosing a sleep stress supplement often means deciding which ingredient approach fits your routine. Do you want a broad blend that touches hormones, mood, and rest? A simpler herbal capsule? Something built around 5-HTP? Or a mineral such as magnesium glycinate? The four products in this guide answer that question differently, so the best way to choose is to compare their ingredients, formats, and listed prices side by side.
Quick take
- 10-In-1 Cortisol Support for Women - A women-focused, multi-ingredient capsule that includes ashwagandha, rhodiola, holy basil, L-theanine, saffron, and chasteberry.
- Sleep & Stress Support, 60 Vegetable Capsules - A melatonin-free Solgar formula with L-theanine, valerian, and passionflower.
- 5-HTP Caps, Serotonin Support for Sleep and Stress, Supports Weight Loss, 5HTP - A 5-HTP-forward capsule with herbal extracts and nutritional support.
- Magnesium Glycinate 400mg - 120 Capsules - A magnesium glycinate formula with added vitamins B6 and D3.
Listed price comparison
The listed prices here span $11.52 to $20.94, a $9.42 spread. Here's how they line up:
| Product | Listed price | Price bar |
|---|---|---|
| 10-In-1 Cortisol Support for Women | USD 13.95 | |
| Sleep & Stress Support, 60 Vegetable Capsules | USD 20.94 | |
| 5-HTP Caps, Serotonin Support for Sleep and Stress, Supports Weight Loss, 5HTP | USD 12.91 | |
| Magnesium Glycinate 400mg - 120 Capsules | USD 11.52 |
Decision matrix at a glance
Use this table to match your priority to the right product.
| Product | Best for | Key ingredients |
|---|---|---|
| 10-In-1 Cortisol Support for Women | Women seeking a multi-ingredient stress, mood, and sleep blend | Ashwagandha, rhodiola, holy basil, L-theanine, saffron, chasteberry |
| Sleep & Stress Support, 60 Vegetable Capsules | Melatonin-free relaxation support | L-theanine, valerian, passionflower |
| 5-HTP Caps, Serotonin Support for Sleep and Stress, Supports Weight Loss, 5HTP | Serotonin-focused support | 5-HTP plus herbal extracts |
| Magnesium Glycinate 400mg - 120 Capsules | Straightforward magnesium glycinate support | Magnesium glycinate, vitamin B6, vitamin D3 |
Product notes
10-In-1 Cortisol Support for Women - Balance Hormones, Sleep, Stress, Mood & PMS
If you're looking for a single supplement that covers several stress-related angles at once, this 60-capsule formula makes a strong case. The ingredient list includes ashwagandha, rhodiola, holy basil, L-theanine, phosphatidylserine, saffron extract, and chasteberry, plus magnesium glycinate and B vitamins. It's positioned for women and touches sleep, mood, stress, hormones, and PMS support. The formula is marked gluten-free and non-GMO, and it's made with capsule administration. The flip side is that it's a broad blend rather than a simple single-ingredient sleep aid, so if you prefer to keep your supplement stack minimal, this may be more than you need.
Sleep & Stress Support, 60 Vegetable Capsules
Solgar's Sleep & Stress Support takes a simpler route with L-theanine plus valerian and passionflower. It is melatonin-free, gluten-free, wheat-free, dairy-free, and formulated in vegetable capsules, which makes it a good match for someone avoiding gluten, wheat, or dairy. The catch is the highest listed price in this comparison paired with a 60-capsule bottle, so you're paying more for a shorter supply. If your priority is a melatonin-free herbal blend from a named brand, this Solgar product fits that need. The listed expiration date is 11/01/2027, which gives you a clear window for use.
5-HTP Caps, Serotonin Support for Sleep and Stress, Supports Weight Loss, 5HTP
This Fearathe product is the 5-HTP option in the group, with 250mg of 5-HTP per serving plus herbal extracts and nutritional support. The 120-capsule bottle means fewer refills if you use it regularly, and the listed price keeps it near the lower end of the range. The title calls out serotonin support for sleep and stress, and it also mentions weight-loss support, so it may appeal to someone looking for that specific combination. The limitation is that this is a focused serotonin approach, not a broad botanical sleep formula. If you want valerian, passionflower, or a women's blend, this isn't that product.
Magnesium Glycinate 400mg - 120 Capsules
This is the minimal-ingredient option in the group: magnesium glycinate with vitamin B6 and vitamin D3, in 120 capsules. It's listed at the lowest price among the four, making it a practical choice if you want magnesium support without a longer botanical list. The capsule is described as yellow with a neutral flavor, and the formula is marked gluten-free and non-GMO. The trade-off is that the included vitamins mean it's not a pure magnesium-only product, even though magnesium glycinate is the headline ingredient. For someone who wants added B6 and D3, that's a benefit; for someone who wants only magnesium, it's worth noting.
Final recommendation by use case
- For a women-focused, multi-ingredient stress blend: 10-In-1 Cortisol Support for Women gives you ashwagandha, rhodiola, holy basil, L-theanine, and more in one 60-capsule bottle.
- For a melatonin-free herbal approach: Sleep & Stress Support from Solgar pairs L-theanine with valerian and passionflower in vegetable capsules.
- For serotonin support with a larger supply: The Fearathe 5-HTP Caps bottle gives you 120 capsules built around 250mg of 5-HTP.
- For the lowest listed price and a magnesium glycinate formula: The Magnesium Glycinate 400mg bottle adds vitamins B6 and D3 and still comes in below the other options.
